Slab Leak Repair: When to Tunnel vs When to Reroute

Your plumber just delivered some tough news: there’s a leak near your concrete slab foundation. They suggested a repair option, but you don’t love the quote and you want some options. Should you tunnel to fix the leak, or is rerouting your water pipes the better option?

The right answer for your home depends on 3 specific questions: how long is your damaged pipe section, how accessible is the leak, and how close is the leak to your slab?

We asked our Master Plumbers for their best advice for slab leak repairs in unique use cases. We used their modern, tech-driven insights to write this article and guide homeowners towards the single best solution for their home.

Dallas homeowners trust Mother Modern Plumbing for pinpoint slab leak detection services using advanced leak detection equipment. Then, we offer deeply insightful solutions based on nearly a century of local plumbing experience in Dallas.

{{slab-leak-repair="/services/slab-leak-repair"}}

Top 8 Reasons Why Your Slab Leaks

If you’ve narrowed your slab leak repair options down to pipe rerouting vs. tunneling for repairs, you’re dealing with one of these eight common plumbing issues:

1. Pipe corrosion and electrolysis damage
2. Pipe abrasions
3. Pinhole leaks
4. Multiple, widespread leaks
5. Systemic pipe deterioration
6. Cracks in your walls or ceilings
7. Cracks in your slab foundation
8. Hard water and mineral scaling in your water line

Slab leak symptoms involving broken water pipes

Homeowners choosing between these 2 slab leak repair methods notice key symptoms, including an unexplained hike in water bills, wet spots on their floors, and the sound of running water when no taps are on. 

You may also notice unusual plant or mold growth near your foundation, or mold or mildew smells in your floors and walls.

Slab leak symptoms involving damaged sewer lines

Though less frequent, some slab leaks are caused by buried sewer pipes. These occur most frequently in Dallas-area homes when aging cast iron sewer lines begin to corrode or deteriorate.

Other telltale signs of a sewer leak near your slab include foul-smelling water pooling near your foundation, slow drains and sewage backup in your toilets, sinks or showers.

{{fast-plumbing-answers-warning-signs-of-a-slab-leak="/blogs/fast-plumbing-answers-warning-signs-of-a-slab-leak"}}

When to Tunnel vs Rerouting Your Water Line 

First, a quick overview of each type of slab leak repair:

Tunnel repairs involve a localized trench outside the foundation, where your licensed plumber can easily reach an unimpeded broken pipe section.

Water line rerouting establishes a new pathway for a completely new pipe system, in the event your existing pipe damage is inaccessible or travels too close to (or underneath) your slab.

Side-by-side comparison table: tunneling vs pipe rerouting

Slab Leak Tunnel Repairs: Best for Isolated Pipe Leaks

We access the damaged pipe under your home's foundation by digging a tunnel from the exterior perimeter of the house, rather than breaking through the concrete slab and flooring from the inside. 

Tunnel repairs are best for performing a spot repair on a leak while completely avoiding interior disruption.

What’s involved in the repair process:

First, our plumbers pinpoint the exact location of the leak with advanced technology: usually acoustic detection and an accompanying camera inspection via your sewer cleanout. 

Next, a trench is dug outside the foundation, and a horizontal tunnel is dug underneath the slab to the leak's location. Your plumber enters the tunnel to perform the repair using high-quality Schedule 40 PVC pipes.

Then, the tunnel is backfilled and the ground is restored.

Pros:

• Direct, Precise Repairs: Tunneling provides direct, hands-on access to the damaged pipe. This allows for a precise and thorough repair or replacement of the problem area. 
• Retains Original Path: Tunneling allows the sewer line to stay in its original, straight-line path, maintaining the proper slope for effective drainage. 
• Protects Your Home's Interior: Preserve your home's expensive flooring, cabinetry, and interior aesthetics. By accessing the damaged pipe from the exterior, it prevents the need for messy, noisy work that could happen inside your living space.

Cons:

• Issues Under the Slab. Tunneling near your slab is fine. Excavating through or under it causes a slew of issues- not the least of which is higher cost. 
• Not ideal for systemic issues. Tunneling is best for localized fixes- generally not for complete pipe replacement. 

Slab Leak Pipe Rerouting: A New Pathway for Your Pipes

What happens when a damaged or aging pipe that’s too close to your foundation, underneath an inaccessible part of your home, or traveling below extensive outdoor construction or landscaping?

If you don’t want to cut into your foundation or tear up tens of thousands of dollars of existing architecture, consider slab rerouting.

Instead of breaking through your home's concrete slab to fix a leaking pipe, a new, completely separate water line is installed to bypass the damaged section entirely. 

What’s involved in the repair process:

First, the leak is precisely located using non-invasive methods like acoustic leak detection and a camera inspection. 

Next, a new, more accessible route for the water line or sewer line is carefully planned. This route often travels through your home's attic, interior walls, or along the exterior. 

Then, new Schedule 40 PVC pipes are run along this path, and connections are made at the water source and the fixture. Your plumbing system is restored with minimal disruption to your home's foundation or flooring. The old pipe is generally sealed off and abandoned in place. 

Pros:

• A Permanent Solution: Rerouting abandons the old, compromised pipe under your slab and installs a brand-new, modern line. This eliminates the potential for a new leak or break to pop up in a different section of the old pipe.
• No Foundation Risk: Unlike tunneling, rerouting does not require any excavation under your home's foundation. This bypasses the risk of foundation instability, soil disruption, and potential structural damage caused by improper backfilling in DFW's clay soil.
• Long-Term Cost Reduction: The initial cost of rerouting is usually higher. But it provides an unobstructed pipe system that reduces the cost of all future inspections, pipe repairs and maintenance tasks.

Cons:

• Can Disrupt Your Home's Interior: Rerouting often requires running new pipes through walls, ceilings, and attics. This can be more disruptive inside your home than tunneling, which keeps the work entirely outside the house.
• Limited by Your Home's Architecture: It can be difficult or impossible to reroute a pipe due to a home's specific architectural features, such as cathedral ceilings or a lack of accessible space in walls and attics.

When to Choose Slab Leak Tunnel Repairs

Choose tunnel repairs when the damaged pipe section is accessible without damaging your slab foundation, home or outdoor living spaces.  

When your damaged pipe section is under 50 feet in length, our licensed plumbers are able to easily execute spot repairs and partial pipe replacement rather than install a fully new layout.

These partial repairs are optimal for single pinhole leaks, root intrusions, and addressing water line scaling.

Customer scenarios where tunneling is the better choice:

1. Our customer experienced systemic sewer line collapse due to shifting soil and aging cast iron pipe materials. Our Master Plumber optimized tunnel routes to address and replace the affected pipe sections without disturbing a majority of the backyard.
2. Multiple main water line leaks and tree root intrusions sent a Garland homeowner’s water bills through the roof. Thankfully, the water line was adjacent to the home’s foundation and not underneath it- making tunnel repairs the superior option.

When to Choose Slab Leak Pipe Rerouting

Choose pipe rerouting when tunnel repairs would cause significant harm to your existing foundation or home structure. In these cases, a new Schedule 40 PVC reroute saves a good deal of money over more intrusive repairs.

Your newly rerouted pipe is also far more accessible for any future maintenance, inspection, leak location and underground pipe repair services.

As a general rule, rerouting is a superior option for widespread pipe corrosion and electrolysis damage, multiple leaks and intrusions, and systemic pipe deterioration.

Customer scenarios where pipe rerouting is the better choice:

1. A Southlake, TX homeowner reported significant water damage in her slab and subfloor. Leak detection services indicated a broken water pipe underneath her foundation. We chose to reroute a new water line rather than break the slab to perform repairs.
2. We encountered widespread cast iron sewer pipe failure, where the existing sewer main traveled underneath a large patio structure. It was significantly less expensive to reroute the sewer pipes than to break the patio foundation to perform pipe replacement.

Looking for a different slab leak repair option? Empower your research with our comprehensive DFW guide to slab leak repair options.

{{choose-the-best-dallas-slab-leak-repair-option-for-you="/blogs/choose-the-best-dallas-slab-leak-repair-option-for-you"}}

Mother Modern Plumbing’s Recommendation

The choice between pipe rerouting and tunnel repairs depends on the location, severity, and length of the damaged pipe section that’s causing your slab leak.

If you’re dealing with an accessible pipe repair that doesn’t require a complete replacement of the affected water or sewer line, opt for tunnel repairs.

If your damaged underground pipe is underneath your slab or architecture, or if the entire pipe needs to be replaced, consider pipe rerouting.

TABLE: Slab Leak Tunnel Repairs vs Pipe Rerouting Use Cases

*The best repair option for slab leaks in these instances depends heavily on the length and location of your damaged pipe. Choose tunnel repairs for isolated issues in easy-to-reach locations, and rerouting for complex, widespread damage or hard-to-reach locations.

Call Mother for Dallas Slab Leak Repair and Detection

Mother Modern Plumbing’s technicians bring expert, tech-driven water leak repair solutions to every service call. We’re committed to a smarter approach to slab leak remediation.

Whether you need tunnel repairs or a fresh pipe reroute, our plumbers provide the single best solution to your home’s unique issue.

Licensed plumbers. Clear, no-hassle bids. Clean, thoughtful service. Permanent repair solutions. That’s the Mother promise.

Don’t let that underground slab leak damage your home any longer. Call Mother 7 days a week- we’ll have a plumber to you within 24 hours.

{{slab-leak-repair="/services/slab-leak-repair"}}